Climate Change and Wind Power: The Winds of Change
Climate change is projected to alter global wind patterns. In some regions, average wind speeds are expected to decrease, potentially impacting the productivity of wind farms. Simultaneously, the intensity of storms is anticipated to increase, with stronger gusts and more frequent lightning strikes posing risk to wind turbine infrastructures. Producers and their insurers will need to monitor these trends closely.
Article information and share options
More straws in the wind: The importance of wind power
There is currently around 1 terawatt of installed wind power globally, equivalent to the annual electricity consumption of the Netherlands.1 This capacity is expected to double by 2030, even though this will be below net zero targets.2 Wind is already an important part of the electricity mix in many states. The UK, for example, recorded a 29% electricity share from wind power in 2023; it was 18% for the EU over the same period.3,4
Figure 1. A comparison of installed capacities and 2030 target capacities for a.) onshore wind
... and b.) offshore wind for selected countries in gigawatts (GW)
However, climate change will impact wind power. There could be changing wind patterns, reducing wind in many regions; increased storm intensity; growing likelihood of lightning strikes; and heatwaves lowering the lifetime of equipment and increased downtime of the turbines.6,7,8
Taking wind out of sails: Wind droughts
In the second half of 2021, Northwestern Europe suffered a 'wind drought', with wind speeds falling 15% below average.9 This fall is largely associated with Arctic warming, narrowing temperature differentials between the tropics and the pole, and so reducing Northern hemisphere wind speeds. It was not a one-off. In winter 2022, wind speeds again plummeted to 'barely a breeze' over several days.10 Lower than average wind speeds over northern parts of Europe have been associated with development of high-pressure patterns, also referred to as 'blocking', over the northeastern Atlantic and Greenland.11
Wind drought has significant consequences. In September 2021, wind contribution to the UK electricity mix fell to just 2%, necessitating the reignition of two mothballed coal plants.12 In December 2022, the wholesale cost of UK spot electricity rose to a record high, driven by a fall in wind power and a rise in natural gas prices.13
Wind drought can be particularly serious as the relationship between wind and electricity production is not linear. A 10% wind speed decline can result in more than 30% reduced output.14 Wind turbines can only operate above a minimal wind threshold; and productivity is dependent on wind magnitudes, direction, pattern and duration.15
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) states that climate change will affect aggregate global windspeeds with projected average annual wind speeds dropping by 10% by 2100, albeit with large regional variabilities.16 One study suggests 11% of global wind power plants will experience a 5% decrease in average wind speeds in a low emissions scenario (SSP1-2.6, associated with warming below 2°C). This could increase to 18% in a high emissions scenario (SSP5-8.5 associated with warming of above 4°C).17 Risk transfer solutions like index based wind resource volatility cover can help the investors and stakeholders by providing protection against financial risk due to uncertain wind speeds.
Stormy weather: Wind turbines and storms
Most wind turbines are engineered for facing winds of 112 mph, equivalent of a category 3 hurricane.18 Speeds above this can damage rotors and even bring down turbines.19 Extreme wind speeds also affect productivity as turbines shut down beyond a certain threshold to avoid damages.
Tropical cyclones and severe storms impact power generation in two ways: by shutting the turbines at high speeds and possible infrastructure damage. By and large, wind farms have proved robust in coping with storms. Hurricane Harvey passed over several wind farms in Texas in 2017, leaving them largely unscathed.20 However, strong enough winds cause damage. Typhoons Jebi and Cimarron toppled over several turbines in Japan in 2018.21 Windstorms caused rotors to become detached in Scotland in 2023; while a tornado brought down five turbines in Iowa in 2024.22,23
Observations indicate a global decrease or no change in the frequency of tropical cyclones, however, the proportion of major tropical cyclone intensities (Category 3-5) has increased. This evolution is projected to continue in the decades ahead. An increase in the average and peak wind speeds during cyclones is also expected because of climate change.24,25 Additionally, tropical cyclones are projected to shift northwest and north,26 with greater impact on eastern China, Japan and Korea among others.27 Damages caused by more intense storms will be compounded by rising sea levels, inland flooding from extensive rainfall, and changes in wave patterns.28,29
Figure 2. Projected changes in climatic-impact driver changes as per IPCC AR6 WG1 for mid-21st century for warming levels of 2°C to 2.4°C for selected regions
Hot sparks: Lightning strikes and rising temperatures
An estimated 5.4% of turbine blades are hit by lightning every year with significant regional variation.30 Despite protection systems, lightning strikes cause 60% of operational blade losses and 20% of operational wind losses.31,32 With climate change, lightning frequency is estimated to increase by 12% for every 1°C warming (Figure 3).33 US could see a 50% increase in lightning strikes by 2100.34 Increases in turbine tower and rotor size increase likelihood of lightning strikes. In 2030, wind turbines with heights of 230-250 m are expected, roughly 80% of the height of the Eiffel Tower.35
Extreme heat events with a 10% pre-industrial probability have a 30% chance of occurring today.36 Temperatures of 35-45°C can impact the life of battery cells and other equipment. Turbines may be designed to shut down when temperatures go beyond 45°C to prevent damages, but this can result in lower outputs from the wind farms.37
Climate change, wind power and implications for insurers
- Planning expected electricity output must take account of projected changes in wind speeds: In certain locations, aggregate average windspeeds may fall. Business owners need to include a range of wind projections in planning investments.
- Risk prevention measures must acknowledge growing climate risk. These include turbines with greater wind gust and lightning strike resilience;38,39 as well as greater heat resistance.
- Offshore failures are a lot more expensive than onshore: Offshore turbines can be larger and windspeeds are typically higher. However, post-incident downtimes are longer, and power losses greater. It costs 5-10 times more to replace an off-shore than on-shore turbine.40,41
- Wind investments will inevitably become more risky: Easier sites will be developed first, riskier ones later, and risk will be exacerbated by climate change. Texas, for example, has huge potential for wind power; but has large storm exposure and projected increase in number of days with temperatures over 45℃.42,43
Figure 3. Impact of climate change on weather events and how they impact wind energy systems
References
References
1Renewable Capacity Statistics 2024, IRENA, 2024.
2A. Joshi, Global wind installations will only reach 2TW by 2030, Mercom Clean Energy Insights, 15 December 2023
3Britain's Electricity Explained: 2023 Review, nationalgrideso.com, 9 January 2024
4S. Brown and D. Jones , European Electricity Review 2024, ember-climate.org, 7February 2024
5Global renewable power sector targets 2030, ember-climate.org, accessed 25 March 2024
6Climate Resilience for Energy Security, IEA, 2022.
7Arias, P.A. et al. Technical Summary. In Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA.
8How Wind Farm Operators Can Mitigate Lightning Risk to Turbines, ul.com, 20 April 2022.
9 B. Beaubouef, ‘Global stilling’ poses challenge to offshore wind market, offshore-mag.com, 7 February 2023.
10 T. Moore, UK and western Europe in middle of a wind drought - and a 'global stilling' is coming, 12 December 2022
11 Low winds, climate.copernicus.eu, accessed 3 June 2024.
12 B. Beaubouef, Global stilling’ poses challenge to offshore wind market, offshore-mag.com, 7 February 2023.
13 B. Beaubouef, Global stilling’ poses challenge to offshore wind market, offshore-mag.com, 7 February 2023.
14 J. Robbins, Global ‘Stilling’: Is Climate Change Slowing Down the Wind?, e360.yale.edu, 13 September 2022.
15 Climate Risk and Adaptation in the Electric Power Sector, Asian Development Bank, 2012.
16 J. Robbins, Global ‘Stilling’: Is Climate Change Slowing Down the Wind?, e360.yale.edu, 13 September 2022.
17 Climate Resilience for Energy Security, IEA, 2022.
18 J. Masters, Offshore Wind Farms: Allaying Concerns About Hurricanes and About Fishing, wunderground.com, 22 January 2019.
19 Solar and wind projects in Asia: How prioritising risk management can enhance project bankability for developers, Marsh, 2023.
20 B.Eckhouse, Harvey Pushed This Texas Wind Farm All the Way to the Max, BloombergNEF, 31 August 2017
21 Wind turbines in Japan suffered by typhoons and earthquakes, Japan Windpower Association, 18 Augst 2018
22 K. Heren, Shocking moment wind turbine is blown apart after Storm Gerrit brought 85mph winds to Britain, LBC, 28 December 2023
23 S. Murphy, 5 massive turbines crumpled as Iowa wind farm suffers rare direct hit from powerful tornado, Fortune, 23 May 2024
24 Climate Resilience for Energy Security, IEA, 2022.
25 P.A. Arias, et al. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA.
26 R. Fuchs, et al. Assessment of Offshore Wind Energy Opportunities and Challenges in the US Gulf of Mexico, NREL, 2023.
27 Climate Resilience for Energy Security, IEA, 2022.
28 L. Xu et al. Resilience of renewable power systems under climate risks, Nature Reviews Electrical Engineering, 1(1), 2024.
29 Z. Wen et al. Assessment of the tropical cyclone-induced risk on offshore wind turbines under climate change, Natural Hazards, 2024.
30 Effects of Evolving NatCat Risks on Reliability and Insurability of Renewable Assets, powermag.com, 1 May 2023.
31 GCube Lists Most Common Wind Insurance Claims, nawindpower.com, 6 August 2013.
32 Managing the lightning risk of wind turbines, global.lockton.com, 22 March 2022.
33 How Wind Farm Operators Can Mitigate Lightning Risk to Turbines, ul.com, 20 April 2022.
34 R. Bates, How Lightning Damage Affects Insurance Markets, nardac.com, 11 May 2022.
35 Offshore Wind Energy Development in Brazil, CEBRI, November 2021.
36 O. Hoegh Guldberg et al. Impacts of 1.5 C global warming on natural and human systems, 2018.
37 Climate Resilience for Energy Security, IEA, 2022.
38 M. Beck, Solar and wind projects in Asia: How prioritising risk management can enhance project bankability for developers, Marsh, 11 July 2023.
39 M. Beck, Solar and wind projects in Asia: How prioritising risk management can enhance project bankability for developers, Marsh, 11 July 2023.
40 Underwriting the transition to renewable energy, AXA XL, December 2022.
41 Discussing Insurance and Fire Risks of Wind Turbines, firetrance.com, accessed 15 May 2024.
42 Climate Resilience for Energy Security, IEA, 2022.
43 What Climate Change Means for Texas, nepis.epa.gov, August 2016.